Skip to content

Did you know?

You can make us an offer.

The price on the page is not the only way to buy. Tell us what you would like to pay and the studio will reply by email.

  1. 1Choose your piece, metal and diamond.
  2. 2Tell us the price you have in mind.
  3. 3The studio reviews it and replies by email.

Up to 3 offers per piece. No payment details needed to send one.

Colored diamonds · Journal

Does Clarity Matter in a Colored Diamond?

Clarity matters less in a colored diamond because body color hides small inclusions. Learn which grades are enough and when clarity still counts.

By Steven V., Master Jeweler, 20+ YearsUpdated 3 min read

A yellow diamond held on the lit stage of a gemological microscope in a laboratory
In this article

Quick answer

Clarity matters less in a colored diamond than in a white one. Body color masks small inclusions, and the busy facet patterns used for colored stones hide them further. Color drives the look and the value. For most yellow, pink and blue diamonds, a stone that is clean to the naked eye is all you need, and paying extra for very high clarity adds nothing you can see. Clarity counts more in pale stones, large stones and step cuts.

Why does clarity matter less when a diamond has color?

  1. Color camouflages. A tiny white or gray inclusion stands out against a colorless background. Against saturated yellow or pink it blends in.
  2. The cuts hide more. Colored diamonds are usually cut as radiants, cushions and ovals with many small facets. That broken-up pattern scatters the view into the stone.
  3. The eye goes to color. When you look at a colored diamond you notice hue and strength first. Clarity features have to be large to compete.

The market reflects this. Between two colored diamonds, a stronger color grade is worth far more than a higher clarity grade.

A magnified view into a cushion-cut yellow diamond showing a small dark crystal and a white feather inclusion
Inclusions seen under strong magnification. At normal viewing distance, color makes marks like these hard to find. Illustration.

Which clarity grade is enough?

Clarity grade In a colored diamond
FL, IF, VVS1, VVS2 Flawless to the eye. The premium over VS is rarely visible.
VS1, VS2 Clean to the eye in almost every stone. A safe, sensible choice.
SI1 Usually clean to the eye in saturated colors and brilliant-style cuts.
SI2 Depends on the stone. Check where the inclusions are.
I1 and below Inclusions visible, and may affect durability.

The grades themselves are explained in the diamond clarity chart, VS clarity guide, SI clarity guide and VS vs SI comparison.

When does clarity still matter?

  • Pale colors. A Fancy Light or Light stone has little color to hide behind. Treat it more like a white diamond.
  • Step cuts. Emerald and asscher cuts have large open facets that act as windows. Choose VS2 or better. See why step cuts need higher clarity.
  • Large stones. Above about 3 carats, facets are bigger and inclusions easier to see.
  • Dark inclusions under the table. One black crystal in the center of the top facet is more visible than several pale ones near the edge.
  • Durability. A feather that reaches the surface near a point or corner is a weak spot whatever the color. See the diamond inclusions guide.

Does it differ by color?

Color How forgiving Notes
Yellow Forgiving Strong yellows hide pale inclusions well.
Pink Moderately forgiving Pink is often light, so check it by eye.
Blue Moderately forgiving Light blues show more than deep ones.
Black Not applicable Opaque, so clarity is not graded. Judge the surface instead.

For black diamonds, see are black diamond rings durable.

Is clarity different in lab-grown colored diamonds?

The grading scale is the same. Lab-grown diamonds can contain their own kinds of inclusions, such as tiny dark pinpoints from the growth process, and graders record them in the same way. In practice lab-grown colored diamonds are widely available in high clarity, so you seldom have to trade clarity against color. See do lab-grown diamonds have inclusions.

How should you rank the factors when buying?

  1. Color: hue and strength. This is what you are buying. See how colored diamonds are graded.
  2. Shape and cut: they determine how much of that color you see. See the best shapes for fancy color.
  3. Carat: size also deepens color.
  4. Clarity: clean to the eye, and structurally sound.

If your budget forces a choice, move down a clarity grade before you move down a color grade.

How do you check that a stone is clean to the eye?

  • Look at it face-up from normal viewing distance, about a hand's length from your eye, in daylight.
  • Ask for video as well as photos. Inclusions that vanish in a still image can show as the stone turns.
  • Read the clarity diagram on the report to see where the marks are. Near the edge is better than under the table.
  • Remember that prongs can cover inclusions at the edge.

Browse yellow, pink and blue diamond engagement rings, or read the fancy colored diamonds guide and the diamond buying guide.

Frequently asked questions

Is VVS clarity worth paying for in a colored diamond?

Rarely. You cannot see the difference from VS without magnification, and the money has more effect spent on color or size.

Can inclusions change the color?

Occasionally. A large dark inclusion can make a stone look grayer, and a colored inclusion can reflect through the facets. Small ones have no effect.

Are colored diamonds more included than white ones?

Natural colored diamonds often are, because buyers accept lower clarity in exchange for rare color. Lab-grown colored diamonds are commonly high clarity.

Does clarity affect sparkle?

Only at the lowest grades, where clouds or many inclusions block light.

Is SI1 acceptable for a pink diamond?

It can be if the stone is clean to the eye. Pink is often light, so look carefully before deciding.

Put it into practice

Engagement rings to start from

Every design in any shape, metal and carat, with an IGI-certified lab-grown or GIA-certified natural diamond.

Shop engagement rings

Certification

Certified, every piece

Engagement rings come with an IGI or GIA certificate, and every other piece with a Diamond Studio certificate of authenticity.

Still deciding? Ask the people who make it.

Amit, Shimi and Steven V. answer questions from our Fifth Avenue studio, by message or on a call.

Or follow along

Your bag (0)

Your bag is empty.

Start with a ring, then add the matching band and earrings.

Explore engagement rings