In this article
Quick answer
Asscher and emerald cuts need higher clarity because their broad, flat facets give a clear view into the diamond. A round brilliant breaks light into many small flashes that hide inclusions; a step cut reflects light in wide planes, so a crystal or cloud can sit in plain sight.
- Round and other brilliant cuts: VS2 and many SI1 stones look clean to the eye.
- Asscher and emerald cuts: VS1 or better is the safer choice; a VS2 needs a close look at the actual stone.
In lab-grown diamonds the price gap between clarity grades is usually smaller than in natural diamonds, so the step up is easier to justify.
How step cuts handle light
A round brilliant has 57 or 58 facets angled to scatter light into small, bright flashes. That busy pattern, called scintillation, camouflages small inclusions. A step cut is built differently. Rows of long, rectangular facets run parallel to the edge of the stone and step down from a wide table, like stairs. The result is the "hall of mirrors" look: broad flashes of light and dark that open and close as the diamond moves.
That open view is what makes step cuts so elegant, and also why they are less forgiving. Looking into an emerald cut is a little like looking through a window. A dark crystal, a feather under the table or a patch of clouds is far easier to spot than it would be in a round, oval or radiant. Read more in our guides to the emerald cut and the Asscher cut.
Which clarity grade to choose
| Clarity | Round brilliant | Asscher or emerald cut |
|---|---|---|
| VVS1 to VVS2 | Clean to the eye | Clean to the eye, even in large stones |
| VS1 | Clean to the eye | Usually clean to the eye |
| VS2 | Clean in most stones | Often clean; check the individual stone |
| SI1 | Often clean | Inclusions frequently visible |
| SI2 | Sometimes clean | Inclusions usually visible |
Two things shift the answer. Size matters, because a larger step cut has a wider table and a bigger window into the stone. Location matters too: an inclusion right under the table is the most visible, while one tucked near a corner or the girdle is much harder to see.
What is different about lab-grown step cuts
Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds, graded on the same clarity scale as natural ones, but their inclusions come from the way they grow. HPHT diamonds can contain small metallic flux inclusions. CVD diamonds can show tiny dark pinpoints or faint graining. In a brilliant cut these often vanish in the sparkle; in a step cut they can show.
Some CVD diamonds also have strain that gives a slightly hazy or grey look. An open step-cut table makes this more noticeable, and a clarity grade does not always describe it. Transparency matters as much as the letter grade, so ask for a video in natural light, not only the report.
Color and price in step cuts
Step cuts can show body color a little more than a round brilliant, because there is less sparkle to distract the eye. Colorless grades from D to F keep an emerald or Asscher cut looking crisp and icy, especially in white gold or platinum settings.
Our engagement ring center diamonds come in E / VS1 (Standard), E / VVS2 and D / VVS2 (Top Shelf), plus a limited D–F / VVS1 Showstopper upgrade. Each of these sits at VS1 or above, the range that suits a step cut, and choosing an Asscher or emerald shape does not change the price at the same carat and grade. Lab-grown centers come with an IGI report. See solitaire engagement rings for settings that show off a step cut.
Mistakes to avoid
- Saving on clarity with an SI step cut, then seeing the inclusion every day.
- Judging by the grade alone without checking where inclusions sit.
- Ignoring haziness or strain in a lab-grown stone because the grade looks good on paper.
Frequently asked questions
Is VS2 clarity good enough for an emerald cut diamond?
Sometimes. In a smaller stone, a VS2 with inclusions near the edges can look clean. In a larger emerald cut with a wide table, VS1 or higher is safer. Always check a video or close photos of the actual diamond.
Do Asscher cuts hide inclusions better than emerald cuts?
Only a little. Asscher cuts usually have a smaller table and a higher crown, which gives a busier reflection pattern. Both are open step cuts, though, and both show inclusions more readily than brilliant cuts.
Is VVS clarity worth it for a lab-grown step cut?
For many stones VS1 already looks clean. VVS adds a margin of safety in larger Asscher and emerald cuts, and because lab-grown clarity premiums are modest, the upgrade often costs less than people expect.
Can an emerald cut diamond look cloudy?
Yes, if it has fine clouds or strain that reduce transparency. Step cuts reveal this more because the open table gives a clear view into the stone. Look at the diamond in natural light before deciding.



