Skip to content

Did you know?

You can make us an offer.

The price on the page is not the only way to buy. Tell us what you would like to pay and the studio will reply by email.

  1. 1Choose your piece, metal and diamond.
  2. 2Tell us the price you have in mind.
  3. 3The studio reviews it and replies by email.

Up to 3 offers per piece. No payment details needed to send one.

Natural diamonds · Journal

Why Do Some Buyers Still Choose Natural Diamonds?

Lab-grown diamonds now lead engagement ring sales, yet many buyers still choose natural. Here are the real reasons: rarity, age, tradition, resale and meaning.

By Steven V., Master Jeweler, 20+ YearsUpdated 2 min read

A natural round diamond solitaire ring on an antique leather-bound book beside a brass magnifier
In this article

Quick answer

Because for some people, where a diamond came from is part of what it means. Natural diamonds formed deep in the earth over a billion years or more, supply is finite, and they carry a long tradition. They also keep more of their value on resale than lab-grown diamonds, though neither is an investment. Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds with the same look and hardness at a lower cost, and they are now the majority choice for engagement rings in the US. Neither choice is wrong; it depends on what matters to you.

What are the main reasons?

Reason What buyers say
Rarity Finite natural supply feels special
Age and origin A stone formed over a billion years ago
Tradition Matches family rings or expectations
Relative value Holds more resale value than lab-grown
Community impact Mining supports jobs in producer countries such as Botswana
Heirloom feeling Wants a stone that feels irreplaceable
Three generations of hands stacked on linen, the oldest wearing a vintage diamond ring
For many families, a natural diamond is part of a story passed down. Illustration.

Is rarity real?

Yes. Natural diamond production comes from a limited number of mines, and large high-quality crystals are uncommon. Lab-grown production can be scaled up. See where natural diamonds come from and how old natural diamonds are.

Does a natural diamond hold value?

Better than lab-grown, but not fully. Resale offers are usually well below the retail price, and natural prices have softened in recent years. Lab-grown resale value is very low. See what a natural diamond is worth second-hand and will lab-grown prices keep falling.

Is natural more or less ethical?

It depends on sourcing. Responsibly mined diamonds support economies in producer countries; poorly managed mining harms people and land. Lab-grown avoids mining but uses a lot of energy. Ask about documented origin and energy sources. See can you trace where a diamond was mined and the ethical diamond guide.

How do you decide?

  • Choose natural if origin, rarity and tradition matter most to you.
  • Choose lab-grown if you want the largest, highest-grade diamond for your budget.
  • Compare in person or on video: they look the same. See can a jeweler tell them apart.

Read lab-grown diamond myths and is it okay to propose with lab-grown.

Which can you choose at Diamond Studio?

Both. Natural centers from 1 to 3 carats come with a GIA report; lab-grown centers from 1 to 8 carats come with an IGI report. Browse engagement rings, natural round and natural oval styles, and the natural diamond guide.

Frequently asked questions

Is a natural diamond better than lab-grown?

Not physically. They are the same material; the difference is origin, price and value retention.

Yes. Many couples still choose natural, though lab-grown is now the majority for US engagement rings.

Will I get a smaller diamond if I choose natural?

Usually, for the same budget.

Can a ring mix natural and lab-grown?

It is possible, but most rings use one type throughout.

What if my partner prefers natural?

Talk about it early. Preference matters more than price for a ring worn every day.

Put it into practice

Engagement rings to start from

Every design in any shape, metal and carat, with an IGI-certified lab-grown or GIA-certified natural diamond.

Shop engagement rings

Certification

Certified, every piece

Engagement rings come with an IGI or GIA certificate, and every other piece with a Diamond Studio certificate of authenticity.

Still deciding? Ask the people who make it.

Amit, Shimi and Steven V. answer questions from our Fifth Avenue studio, by message or on a call.

Or follow along

Your bag (0)

Your bag is empty.

Start with a ring, then add the matching band and earrings.

Explore engagement rings