In this guide
Quick answer
To buy a colored gemstone well, judge color first, then clarity, cut and carat, and always ask whether the stone is natural, lab-created or treated. Match its hardness to how it will be worn.
- Color: hue, tone and saturation set most of the value
- Clarity: standards differ by gem; emeralds are expected to show inclusions
- Cut: even brightness with no dull, see-through center
- Lab-made or treated: must be disclosed
- Durability: check hardness before choosing a ring
Color: hue, tone and saturation
Gemologists describe color in three parts. Hue is the basic color, such as blue or green. Tone is how light or dark it is. Saturation is how strong and pure it is. The most valued stones usually have a pure hue, a medium to medium-dark tone and strong saturation. Brown or gray overtones lower value in almost every gem.
Always look at a stone in more than one light. Daylight, warm indoor bulbs and cool shop lighting can make the same sapphire or tourmaline look quite different. If you are buying online, ask for videos in daylight and indoor light.
Clarity, cut and size
There is no single clarity scale for colored stones. Aquamarine, topaz and citrine usually grow clean, so visible inclusions are a real drawback. Emerald, red tourmaline and many rubies normally show inclusions, and buyers accept more. The question is whether inclusions dull the color, look distracting or weaken the stone.
Colored stones are often cut to save weight, which can leave a flat, see-through window in the middle or a bulky bottom that adds carats you cannot see. Compare stones by their millimeter size, not only carat weight, because gems differ in density; a one-carat sapphire looks smaller than a one-carat aquamarine.
Natural, lab-created, treated and imitation
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Natural | Formed in the earth |
| Lab-created | Same material, grown in a lab (sapphire, ruby, emerald, spinel) |
| Treated | Natural stone improved by heat, oil, filling or irradiation |
| Imitation | A different material, such as glass, made to look like the gem |
Treatments are common and many are stable, but they affect value and care. Our gemstone treatment guide covers each one. For an important stone, ask for a report from GIA or another independent gemological laboratory that states the species, whether it is natural, any treatment detected and, where relevant, an opinion on origin.
Match the stone to the jewelry
A ring takes knocks every day; earrings and pendants rarely do. Stones at 8 or above on the Mohs scale, such as sapphire, ruby, alexandrite and spinel, suit daily rings. Softer stones like opal, tanzanite and pearl are better in earrings, pendants or occasional rings. See the gemstone hardness guide and our overview of gemstone engagement rings.
Questions to ask before you buy
- Is it natural or lab-created, and has it been treated?
- Is there an independent laboratory report?
- What are its exact measurements in millimeters?
- What is the return window, and does it cover custom or resized pieces?
- Is there a warranty on the setting and stones?
Diamond Studio makes diamond jewelry only, in lab-grown or natural diamonds. If you would rather choose a diamond, browse our fine jewelry, which comes with free insured shipping and 60-day returns.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between precious and semi-precious stones?
Traditionally, diamond, ruby, sapphire and emerald were called precious and all others semi-precious. Gemologists now avoid the split, because a fine spinel or tourmaline can be worth more than a poor sapphire.
Are lab-created gemstones real?
Yes. A lab-created sapphire, ruby or emerald has the same chemistry and crystal structure as the natural stone. It is not an imitation, but it should be clearly disclosed and is usually priced lower.
Which gemstones hold their value best?
Fine, untreated or lightly treated sapphire, ruby and emerald with strong color tend to be most sought after. Most gemstones are best bought for enjoyment rather than as an investment.
How do I know a gemstone is genuine?
Buy from a seller who discloses origin and treatment in writing, and for valuable stones ask for an independent laboratory report. A gemologist can also test a stone you already own.



