Skip to content

Did you know?

You can make us an offer.

The price on the page is not the only way to buy. Tell us what you would like to pay and the studio will reply by email.

  1. 1Choose your piece, metal and diamond.
  2. 2Tell us the price you have in mind.
  3. 3The studio reviews it and replies by email.

Up to 3 offers per piece. No payment details needed to send one.

Style and fine jewelry basics · Guide

Fine Jewelry Buying Guide: What to Check Before You Buy

Before buying fine jewelry, check the metal stamp, the diamond's documentation and how stones are set, then the seller's returns, warranty and aftercare.

By Steven V., Master Jeweler, 20+ YearsUpdated 3 min read

Fine Jewelry Buying Guide: What to Check Before You Buy
In this guide

Quick answer

To buy fine jewelry well, check six things before you pay:

  1. Metal: solid 14K or 18K gold or platinum, stamped inside.
  2. Stones: natural or lab-grown clearly stated, with a grading report for a center diamond.
  3. Construction: even prongs, secure clasps and solid, not hollow, metal.
  4. Returns: a window long enough to inspect it, and whether custom pieces are included.
  5. Warranty and aftercare: what is covered and who does repairs.
  6. A real person: someone who answers questions before and after you buy.

Fine jewelry is made from solid precious metal and genuine stones, so it should last for decades. The difference between a good and a disappointing purchase usually comes down to details you can check in advance. If you are not sure which category a piece falls into, start with fine jewelry vs fashion jewelry.

Read the metal stamp

Stamp What it means
14K or 585 Solid gold, 58.3% pure
18K or 750 Solid gold, 75% pure
PT950 or PT900 Platinum, 95% or 90% pure
925 Sterling silver, 92.5% silver
GP, GEP, HGE or GF Gold plated or gold filled over another metal, not solid gold

Our jewelry stamps guide covers less common marks.

Diamonds and their paperwork

Lab-grown and natural diamonds are both real diamonds, but they differ in price and rarity, so the seller must say which you are buying. Weigh the two in lab-grown vs natural diamonds.

  • Center stones: expect an independent grading report, such as IGI or GIA, stating carat, color, clarity and measurements. Check that the report number matches the stone.
  • Accent and pavé diamonds: these are rarely graded one by one. Look for a stated total carat weight and a quality range.
  • Cut: for round diamonds, cut quality affects sparkle more than any other grade.

Check the construction

  • Prongs should be even and grip each stone, which should sit level.
  • Bracelets and necklaces need clasps with a safety catch.
  • Earring backs should hold firmly; screw backs add security for larger studs.
  • Solid pieces resist dents better than hollow ones of the same size.
  • The inside of a ring should be smooth and polished, with no sharp edges.

Questions to ask the seller

  1. How long is the return window, and does it include made-to-order or engraved pieces?
  2. What does the warranty cover, and for how long?
  3. Is shipping insured, and is a signature required?
  4. How long does a made-to-order piece take?
  5. Can resizing, tightening and cleaning be done later?
  6. Can I talk to someone before I order?

For reference, here is how Diamond Studio answers them. Every piece is made new to order and arrives in about 2 to 2½ weeks. Shipping is free and insured worldwide, with a signature on delivery. Returns are accepted within 60 days on everything, including made-to-order, engraved and customized pieces. Lab-grown diamonds carry a lifetime warranty against cracking, damage and clouding while in your possession, and lost or loose accent diamonds are covered too. Full details are on our return policy and warranty page, and you can book a call with the owners before you buy.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing prices without comparing grades, metal weight and setting quality.
  • Assuming "gold" means solid gold without checking the stamp.
  • Buying a custom piece from a seller that does not accept returns on it.
  • Skipping insurance on a valuable piece; warranties do not cover loss or theft.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to buy fine jewelry online?

It can be, if the seller states the materials clearly, ships insured with a signature, gives you enough time to inspect and return the piece, and lets you talk to a person. Check that any grading report matches the item you receive.

What is the difference between a grading report and a certificate of authenticity?

A grading report comes from an independent lab and describes one specific diamond's grades and measurements. A certificate of authenticity is issued by the seller and confirms the metal and diamond quality of the finished piece.

Is 14K or 18K gold better value?

14K is harder and wears better on rings and bracelets used every day. 18K has more gold and a richer color, at a higher price. Both are solid gold and do not tarnish.

Should I insure fine jewelry?

For valuable pieces, it is worth considering. A warranty covers defects, not loss or theft. Check exactly what a policy covers, keep receipts and reports, and get a professional appraisal for higher-value items.

Put it into practice

Fine jewelry to wear every day

Earrings, necklaces and bracelets, each with a Diamond Studio certificate of authenticity.

Shop fine jewelry

Still deciding? Ask the people who make it.

Amit, Shimi and Steven V. answer questions from our Fifth Avenue studio, by message or on a call.

Or follow along

Your bag (0)

Your bag is empty.

Start with a ring, then add the matching band and earrings.

Explore engagement rings