Skip to content

Did you know?

You can make us an offer.

The price on the page is not the only way to buy. Tell us what you would like to pay and the studio will reply by email.

  1. 1Choose your piece, metal and diamond.
  2. 2Tell us the price you have in mind.
  3. 3The studio reviews it and replies by email.

Up to 3 offers per piece. No payment details needed to send one.

Carat, size and price · Journal

Are Diamonds Actually Rare?

Diamond itself is not especially rare, but large, colorless, nearly flawless natural diamonds are. What makes a diamond rare, and where lab-grown fits.

By Steven V., Master Jeweler, 20+ YearsUpdated 4 min read

A jeweler's scoop overflowing with many small loose diamonds
In this article

Quick answer

Partly. Diamond as a material is not especially rare: natural diamonds are mined on several continents every year, and lab-grown diamonds can be grown in a few weeks. What is rare is a natural diamond that combines size, high color and high clarity, and rarity climbs steeply with each step up.

  • Common: small, included or brownish natural rough, much of which never becomes jewelry
  • Uncommon: natural diamonds over 1 carat with good color and clarity
  • Rare: large, colorless, flawless natural stones and vivid pink, blue or red diamonds

The answer depends on which diamond you mean. Rarity is not one fact about the mineral but a ladder of size and quality, and only the top rungs are genuinely scarce. For a full breakdown of what goes into the price, see why diamonds are so expensive.

Why natural diamonds take so much finding

Natural diamonds formed deep in the earth's mantle, roughly 90 to 120 miles down, under heat and pressure that exist only at that depth. Most are more than a billion years old.

They reached the surface in rare, deep-source volcanic eruptions that left columns of rock called kimberlite pipes. Many kimberlites hold few or no diamonds, and only a small share are rich enough to mine. Even a productive mine crushes and sorts very large volumes of rock to recover a small weight of diamond.

Sorting narrows the supply again. Much of the rough recovered is small, heavily included or brownish and never becomes a polished gem. Cutting then removes a large part of each crystal's weight, so a polished 2-carat diamond starts as a much larger piece of rough.

What makes one diamond rarer than another

Each quality factor narrows the supply, and the factors multiply. A diamond that is large, colorless and nearly flawless is far rarer than one that is only large or only colorless.

Factor Easier to find Harder to find
Carat Under 1 carat 2 carats and above, rarer still past 3
Color G to J (near colorless) and below D to F (colorless), with D the rarest
Clarity SI1, SI2 and I grades VVS1, VVS2, IF and FL
Fancy color Yellow and brown Strong pink, blue, green and red

Size has the strongest effect. Large rough is much scarcer than small rough, so price per carat climbs with weight: a single 2-carat diamond costs far more than two 1-carat diamonds of the same grade. Cut works differently. It reflects the cutter's skill and choices rather than nature's supply, and a well-cut stone of modest grades often looks better than a rarer stone cut poorly. The 4 Cs of diamonds explains each grade, and fancy colored diamonds covers natural color beyond white.

Rarity, supply and the price you pay

Price has never tracked geology alone. For much of the 20th century, a few producers controlled most of the world's rough and released it carefully, while advertising tied diamonds to engagements. Steady supply and strong demand kept prices high and made diamonds feel rarer than the mining alone would suggest.

The retail price also covers cutting, independent grading, the setting and the work of making the piece. Where natural rarity shows most clearly is at the very top: large D flawless stones and vivid pinks and blues sit in a different price world from everyday fine jewelry.

Where lab-grown diamonds fit

Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds, with the same carbon crystal, the same hardness of 10 on the Mohs scale and the same refractive index of 2.42. They are grown by HPHT or CVD over a few weeks, so supply is limited by production capacity rather than geology. A large, colorless, high-clarity lab-grown stone is easy to source, which is why lab-grown diamonds cost less. The Knot's 2026 Real Weddings Study found that 61% of engagement rings had a lab-grown center diamond.

Part of a natural diamond's appeal is its age and origin; a lab-grown diamond's appeal is more size and quality for the budget. To the eye they look the same. Compare them in lab-grown vs natural diamonds.

At Diamond Studio, every piece is available with lab-grown or natural diamonds. Engagement ring center diamonds are lab-grown from 1 to 8 carats with an IGI report, or natural from 1 to 3 carats with a GIA report. Browse engagement rings to see both options.

Frequently asked questions

Do diamonds hold their value?

Usually only in part. Natural diamonds typically resell for well below their retail price, and lab-grown diamonds resell for much less. It is best to think of a diamond as something to wear and enjoy rather than a store of value.

Is a lab-grown diamond worth less because it is not rare?

It costs less because it can be grown to order rather than mined, not because it is a lesser diamond. It has the same crystal structure, hardness and sparkle as a natural diamond of the same grade.

Which diamond color is the rarest?

Red is generally considered the rarest diamond color, followed by strongly saturated pinks, blues and greens. Among white diamonds, D is the rarest color grade.

Is a diamond rarer than a ruby or emerald?

Not always. Fine rubies, emeralds and alexandrites in larger sizes are generally harder to find than white diamonds of similar size. Rarity depends on the quality of the individual stone, not only on the gem type.

Can you tell a natural diamond from a lab-grown one by eye?

No. A gemological lab separates them with specialized instruments, and the grading report states the origin. Many lab-grown diamonds also carry a tiny laser inscription on the girdle.

Put it into practice

Engagement rings to start from

Every design in any shape, metal and carat, with an IGI-certified lab-grown or GIA-certified natural diamond.

Shop engagement rings

Certification

Certified, every piece

Engagement rings come with an IGI or GIA certificate, and every other piece with a Diamond Studio certificate of authenticity.

Still deciding? Ask the people who make it.

Amit, Shimi and Steven V. answer questions from our Fifth Avenue studio, by message or on a call.

Or follow along

Your bag (0)

Your bag is empty.

Start with a ring, then add the matching band and earrings.

Explore engagement rings